PDA

View Full Version : FAMOUS REVAWAT OF HZ. ALI RA IS THAT TRUE?


ALIJAN1001
17th December 2008, 08:15
FROM MY CHILDWOOD, I LISTEN THAT HZ. ALI RA WAS ABOUT TO GO FOR SALLAH AND ONE MEN COME TO HIM AND ASK HIM RA A QUESTION THAT HOW MANY ANIMALS LYING EGGS AND HOW MANY GIVINE BERTH HZ. ALI RA REPLIED THAT THOUSE ANIMALS WHO LYING EGGS DID NOT HAVE VIEWABLE EAR AND THOUSE WHO GIVEING BIRTHER HAVE VIEWABLE ERA.

IS THIS TRUE REVAWAT.
:icon_smile_big:
Ron
17th December 2008, 13:25
Don't capitalize as it means your shouting.
ALIJAN1001
18th December 2008, 04:02
Don't capitalize as it means your shouting.

sorry i wasnot aware of that, will care in future.

thanks.

Syed Alijan Jaffery (Ex.Shia):)
Ron
19th December 2008, 01:46
Thanks for your kind response. Welcome to the forum.

You have made it clear that you're an "ex-Shia" but I hope that does not mean that you find it in your heart to disparage anyone. I believe it would be more productive for you if you were to give us insight into yourself and your experiences without degrading anyone or anything. Right now you've asked several questions but if you've already moved away from "Shia" beliefs then you're not asking a question you don't have an answer to. If you want to guide others I respectfully ask that you choose a different way.
ALIJAN1001
20th December 2008, 10:50
Thanks for your kind response. Welcome to the forum.

You have made it clear that you're an "ex-Shia" but I hope that does not mean that you find it in your heart to disparage anyone. I believe it would be more productive for you if you were to give us insight into yourself and your experiences without degrading anyone or anything. Right now you've asked several questions but if you've already moved away from "Shia" beliefs then you're not asking a question you don't have an answer to. If you want to guide others I respectfully ask that you choose a different way.

thanks for your response.

i did not want to degrade any religion, but i realy want answer of this question, since i do beleived that hz. ali ra was a great sahaabi-e-rasool, i do confirm he ra was very knowledgeable, but as everybody well aware that he ra wasnot masoom, and also i head about snake "anaconda" and "Bull Shark" both are fit to laying egg as per this revayat but they both given berth instead of laying egg.(a)