View Full Version : Omar at Fatimas House???
1st July 2007, 10:59
5th July 2007, 12:15
When some one accuses some other person of a crime, the onus is on him (the accuser) to bring forward reliable evidences. I donít think any one would expect the defendant to go and find evidences against himself (or the one he is defending). It is therefore my understanding that it is the responsibility of our Shia brothers to provide reliable sources of this incident.
Number of sources that are usually referred to by Shia brothers (e.g. Al-Imama wa Al-Syasah, Al Iqd Al-Farid, Qurra Al-Ayn Fi Tafzil Al-Shaykhayn). In none of them is a record that fulfils the following conditions:
∑ Clearly suggesting that Umar RA actually burnt the door or pushed the door on Fatima (RA).
∑ Having reliable chains of narrators (in fact the majority of these sources do not even have a chain of narrator)
∑ Not accompanying with conflicting records.
Please do let me know if there are any sources that fulfil the above three conditions.
I will be more than happy to confirm the reliability of any Hadith that fulfils the above three conditions if a Shia brother brings it to my attention.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.1 Copyright © 2013 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.