PDA

View Full Version : Children Dying as Hunger Stalks Brazil's Indians



The_Other_Admin
18th March 2005, 11:13
DOURADOS, Brazil (Reuters) - Geria's ribs bulge from her emaciated body, but she is alive and luckier than the dozens of Indian children who are starving to death each month on Brazil's federal reservations.


The 20-month-old Kaiowa Indian girl weighed just 11 pounds -- about average for a 3-month-old -- when federal workers took her a month ago to a feeding clinic near the farming town of Dourados in Mato Grosso do Sul state.


Other Indian children in this area known as Brazil's bread basket were not so lucky. At least 14 have died this year on the Dourados reservation, the latest on Thursday.


Called "Brazil's Somalia" and "a concentration camp" by press and politicians, its overcrowded villages are a symbol of Indian poverty in this modernizing country of 180 million, where 40 percent of adults are now overweight.


President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva faces pressure to overhaul failing Indian agencies to achieve his promise of wiping out malnutrition, which affects about a third of Brazilians, by 2006.


For Indians, who live on 318 reserves ranging from vast Amazon tracts to the 12-square-mile reserve near Dourados, the causes of malnutrition can be overcrowding, the breakdown of families and the absence of federal government -- which under Brazil's constitution is responsible for the welfare of Indians who are officially wards of the state.


Infant mortality is up to six times the national average in some tribes in Brazil's interior, although there are almost no infant deaths among more affluent coastal Indians.


As cultural traditions disappear among Dourados' 11,500 Guarani, Kaiowa and Terena Indians, alcoholism and depression often take their place.


"The reservation breeds malnutrition," said Tiburcio Fernandes, as he knelt by his 6-month-old daughter's grave.


He buried Kelly three weeks ago among the corn, manioc and okra plants behind his brick shack in the village of Bororo.


Kelly's problems began when her mother went hungry and ran out of breast milk. She had five other children to support.


Fernandes, 49, delayed taking Kelly to the nearby clinic. Many Indians first use holymen's prayers. They distrust the over-crowded local hospital. Several Indian children went there with diarrhea in February and died of infections.


Sacks of commercial seeds and fertilizer from the government are stacked in his house. He does not know how to use them and there is no one to advise him. Government tractors to plant them broke down last year.


BLAME GAME


Lula rushed food and benefits to Mato Grosso do Sul after February press reports of malnutrition. Health agency Funasa delivered firewood so Indians could cook handouts.


"Indian children are dying in the same ways as they did 40 years ago," says Marilia Troquez, who runs the Dourados feeding clinic. "Everyone is trying to avoid being blamed for this."


Indians in Brazil's interior were confined to reservations last century. Their territories were turned into farms which are now driving vigorous economic growth with boom crops like soy. Some moved to slums near cities like Sao Paulo where they still suffer malnutrition.





A rise in Brazil's Indian population from 400,000 in the late 1980s to over 700,000 in more than 200 tribes now due to better medical care has put pressure on reservations. There were an estimated 5 million Indians when Europeans fist landed in 1500.

More land is one solution and some Mato Grosso do Sul Indians have seized farms at gunpoint.

Dourados' ranchers fear Indians could claim their properties as ancestral lands -- as is their right under Brazil's constitution -- if they can prove it in court.

Some locals still call Indians "bugres," or savages. But there are signs centuries of fear are fading. Dourados' Unigran university grants over 60 Indian scholarships a year and is building a reservation child care and literacy center.

"The Indians' problems are only going to be resolved when whites change their views," said Jairo de Osti, head of Dourados' chamber of commerce.

Among the Indians themselves, there are huge wealth divisions and unequal land distribution. Some families own nearly 100 acres. Fernandes has 1.2 acre (0.5 hectare).

Many illegally rent land to farmers rather than grow food.

"You could spend millions in there, and put in 100 tractors and it would do nothing without land redistribution and trained people," says Israel Bernardo, local director of the government agency responsible for Indian affairs.

Fernandes' 15-year-old daughter Sulene drops her head when asked about school. She married 16 months ago and has a baby. She sees her husband three days every two months when he gets back from the sugarcane plantation where most men work for about $4 a day. Many become alcoholics, some contract tuberculosis and sexually transmitted diseases.

Luciano Arevalo, a leader of the Bororo village says his people have to wean themselves off government dependence.

"Our old ways are finished," said Arevalo. "We need to help ourselves ."

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&u=/nm/20050315/lf_nm/brazil_indians_dc

muhtadiyah
20th March 2005, 00:09
Assalaamu alaikum brother Chuck,

Thank you for the article. It's good to be reminded that suffering isn't limited to our muslim ummah.

I find things like this difficult to read. This is one of the drawbacks of the information age; we are aware of so much more than we can deal with, so much that is out of the sphere of our influence. There is a feeling of helplessness and impotency. For myself, I sometimes need to pull away from watching the news or reading certain kinds of books to keep from sinking in despair.

Of course prayer is not to be discounted, but I think the human spirit which desires peace and justice also looks for a more tangible means of bringing about change. For me, I boycott certain companies which I know commit human rights abuses, and I do some other small efforts, but it still doesn't seem like much.

The painful history of the natives of the Western Hemisphere is often overlooked, and their continued suffering goes on unnoticed. A good introduction to the subject is the "Memory of Fire" trilogy of books by Eduardo Galeano, dealing with Latin America (I haven't read all of them yet). Another good book is "Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee: an Indian History of the American West."

peace,
muhtadiyah

bdb85
20th March 2005, 23:57
The conquest of the North American Indians was indeed brutal, but it pales in comparison to the Spanish/Portugeese conquest of Latin America.
In Argentina and Chile, the entire native population was deliberately exterminated--there are no survivors.
In Peru, the Spaniards took the Inca Emperor hostage, demanded that he fill up two rooms full of gold or die. He did as he was told, but he was beheaded anyway.
In Mexico, the Spaniards infected blankets with small pox and then threw them over the walls of Aztec cities. It is the first instance of biological warfare in the history of the world.

We as Americans also have our fare share of brutality. Alcoholism is rampant among North American Indians, as is poverty. However, I think we are beginning to make restitution to the natives with healthcare, college scholarships, etc--I know its very little and terribly late, but its the least we can do now.

vinod
21st March 2005, 00:42
A must read book on the same subject - "The Lies My Teacher Told Me"

bdb85
21st March 2005, 00:58
I must add that for all this talk of conquest, a lot of the Native deaths in North America were due to disease (inadvertantly carried by Europeans and African slaves )more than wars. And there were brutalities on the Native side as well. Nevertheless, the brutality the Europeans and Americans stooped to is indeed disturbing.

And in some places, such as my area, the Natives were basically married and bred out of existence--I, along with just about everyone else from Tidewater Virginia, have a trace of Powhatan Indian in me.

muhtadiyah
21st March 2005, 00:58
Salaam,

and jazak Allah khair for the recommendation br. Vinod. I vaguely remember hearing of this book before...I'll go see if it's at my local library. But out of curiosity, what lead you to read it? (Aren't you from Singapore?)

Academically, my high school was ranked among the top in the nation, but I have to say that I believe our social studies and history curriculum was absolutely pathetic.

I have a young niece in South America, working with a sort of international missionary team (yes, my friends, she is a mubashirah). Anyway, she confessed to me how absolutely ignorant she feels in european company, and how upset she is with the school system. Which is why, if I ever have children, I will teach them at home in sha' Allah.

peace,
muhtadiyah

vinod
21st March 2005, 08:18
Salam Sister


But out of curiosity, what lead you to read it?
A simple recommendation from a fellow brother actually. But once I picked up the book, I couldn't let go till I finished it. For the first time in my life, I developed a respect for history as a subject of study and realized it's potent influence on our present mindset.

What does 'mubashirah' mean? What's the link between Europen company and South America? :confused:

Was-salam
Vinod

muhtadiyah
22nd March 2005, 02:47
What does 'mubashirah' mean?She's a christian missionary.
What's the link between Europen company and South America? :confused:She is in the company of some young European christians, and they are all in South America at an international missionary program. Now we're all cleared up. :)

peace,
muhtadiyah

The_Other_Admin
22nd March 2005, 03:51
Which is why, if I ever have children, I will teach them at home in sha' Allah.

It is not my place to say this, but in my opinion it will be a bad idea. Send them to a good school and univ.

Anyway, back to the topic. The main purpose of this post was to serve as reminder for suffering of people and something to raise the feelings to help them. I find it strange that Bush can attack Iraq to bring democracy but he is ignoring Somalia a country in immediate need of law and order. More people died in Africa than in the Asian tsunami disaster, but aid efforts never been same as for the later.

But this something for Islamic countries to think about and do something for these people (somali, muslims in other countries, and non-muslims) as it was the sunnah of prophet (p).

However, the discussion turned out to be interesting.

muhtadiyah
24th March 2005, 15:06
It is not my place to say this, but in my opinion it will be a bad idea. Send them to a good school and univ.Salaam br. Chuck,

It would be my intention to send them to a good university. I'm talking about schooling them at home during the more formative years.

I've met parents with as many as 9 home-schooled children, and when they graduated at 16 they were performing at college levels and spoke 3 languages. They were happy, well-mannered, mature and goal-oriented. Then again, I've met publicly schooled children who as adults couldn't tell me who Beethoven or Christopher Columbus was.

I'm not saying every home-schooled child turns out a genius. Much depends on the parents' commitment to develop their talent for teaching. I have met home-schoolers who play nintendo most of the day.

Besides what I perceive as an academic lack in certain areas, I also believe that education should be moral and spiritual, not merely intellectual. And the environment in public schools (and sadly to say, even many Islamic schools from my experience and from what I've heard), often works against those values. I know this from experience.

peace,
muhtadiyah

The_Other_Admin
28th March 2005, 18:14
It would be my intention to send them to a good university. I'm talking about schooling them at home during the more formative years.

<snip>


Salam sister,

Silly me what I was thinking :o

Well, that makes sense; home-schooled children get individual attention compared to publicly-schooled children who get attention divided over 30 to 40 students.